Yeah, the one with Leelee Sobieski was more lacking. Her performance was dry, and it lacked a good sense of Joan's wit and charisma. In the film, I was never convinced that she was sufficiently persuasive and charismatic to rally the troops. Instead she was more of a soft-spoken zealot, which to me didn't work. In the Milla Jovovich version, we get a better sense of her persuasiveness and the troops coming to appreciate her more believably.