though I think the rondels are dished just a little too much. Slightly more flat, and they would be perfect.
Ed, reached this conclusion myself a while back. In period artwork, they appear to be pretty convex, but it bothered me for a long time that when I actually made them I thought it didn't look right to my eye despite being what period depictions seemed to show ( perhaps the result of seeing a 2D depiction of something in 3D ). I shallowed them out a few years back. I'd be happy to replace them for you, no charge.
Al, I can’t remember what year I picked up my rondels from you, but I love them! I can’t count the number of compliments I’ve received over the years and I always point them in your direction.
I was in an SCA tournament in 2012 and a “hold” was called when my opponent wacked a rondel and sent it flying. The marshal seemed very concerned until I proved that it was “armour bling” and the fight could continue without it.