ModernChivalry.org

Main => The Armoury => Topic started by: Sir William on 2015-05-27, 15:55:10

Title: Historical Accuracy in Maille- are Bingo Wings strictly a modern issue?
Post by: Sir William on 2015-05-27, 15:55:10
Hmm...that depends; according to this effigy, BW armor may have been on the field after all:

http://effigiesandbrasses.com/846/3313/

See?  I should've held onto my bell-bottom armed original hauberk.  lol

I'm kidding, I figured that was artistic license moreso than an eye for accuracy.  Am I wrong in that assumption?
Title: Re: Historical Accuracy in Maille- are Bingo Wings strictly a modern issue?
Post by: Sir William on 2015-05-27, 16:04:13
And here's another one, German, Otto von Orlamunde, 1340.

http://effigiesandbrasses.com/3193/3138/

Looks like his sleeve blouses to allow for his brig-style vambrace.  I'd think that'd be a pain to have flapping about in a fight.  Thoughts, anyone?
Title: Re: Historical Accuracy in Maille- are Bingo Wings strictly a modern issue?
Post by: Ian on 2015-05-27, 16:23:25
I've seen a decent chunk of representative artwork that suggests bingo-wings on the forearms are used specifically with forearm armor intentionally worn as the inner layer so the maille is intended to be draped over the rigid protection.  Same with upper arm bingo-wings.  When the rerebrace connects to the doublet, and the maille is bloused over the rerebrace the maille needs bingo-wings to drape properly.  But if maille is the inner-most defense, then it obviously needs to be fitted.  :)  So bingo-wings are historical, IF the maille is being draped over another piece of armor.  I'm sure there are counter-examples, but that's a good rule of thumb.
Title: Re: Historical Accuracy in Maille- are Bingo Wings strictly a modern issue?
Post by: Sir William on 2015-05-27, 17:17:40
That's worth keeping in mind- but I'm reasonably sure I won't go that route.  I didn't care for that look.  I remember you mentioning that in some Italian armors, they'd wear a mail piece instead of pauldrons/spaulders?
Title: Re: Historical Accuracy in Maille- are Bingo Wings strictly a modern issue?
Post by: Ian on 2015-05-27, 19:26:05
Italy ca. 1400

(http://armourinart.com/media/armourinart.com/original/39.jpg)

(http://armourinart.com/media/armourinart.com/original/38.jpg)

ca. 1380

(http://manuscriptminiatures.com/media/fashionablymedieval.com/original/179.jpg)
Title: Re: Historical Accuracy in Maille- are Bingo Wings strictly a modern issue?
Post by: Sir William on 2015-05-27, 19:52:16
Hm.  I actually don't mind the look- let me ask you, do you wear maille below the waist, other than the haubergeon?  That's actually what I really want to avoid.
Title: Re: Historical Accuracy in Maille- are Bingo Wings strictly a modern issue?
Post by: Sir Nate on 2015-05-27, 20:07:03
Good to know
Title: Re: Historical Accuracy in Maille- are Bingo Wings strictly a modern issue?
Post by: Ian on 2015-05-27, 20:21:27
Hm.  I actually don't mind the look- let me ask you, do you wear maille below the waist, other than the haubergeon?  That's actually what I really want to avoid.

The only maille I wear is my haubergeon.  If I ever get a full cuirass, I will convert my maille to something like this:

(https://lh5.googleusercontent.com/-Wjdofx8Yu-o/UsrtoC0ynBI/AAAAAAAACJM/E0YgKQBaGgc/s400/woundedknight.jpg)

**edit**

I do wear a maille pisan on my neck and the aventail... but I meant waist level or below, it's just the haubergeon **
Title: Re: Historical Accuracy in Maille- are Bingo Wings strictly a modern issue?
Post by: Sir William on 2015-05-27, 20:25:12
Why?  To cut down on weight?  That's a 2 piecer, skirt and shirt right?  What do you wear to protect your nether regions?
Title: Re: Historical Accuracy in Maille- are Bingo Wings strictly a modern issue?
Post by: Ian on 2015-05-27, 20:26:30
Why?  To cut down on weight?  That's a 2 piecer, skirt and shirt right?  What do you wear to protect your nether regions?

It's both more comfortable and lighter.  The paunces (skirt of maille) is the only thing that protects the groin, no change from the haubergeon. 
Title: Re: Historical Accuracy in Maille- are Bingo Wings strictly a modern issue?
Post by: Sir James A on 2015-05-28, 02:05:00
Sir Ian covered the Italian armor already, which is the one I know of for the "floppy mail sleeve" style. I don't like citing a modern reference, but since it's Dr Tobias Capwell....

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=wL_yybJ-tNo

(I want that armor. So. Bad.)
Title: Re: Historical Accuracy in Maille- are Bingo Wings strictly a modern issue?
Post by: Sir William on 2015-05-28, 13:01:30
Dr. Capwell is a beast- I want his black harness!  First time I saw it I think I man-swooned.
Title: Re: Historical Accuracy in Maille- are Bingo Wings strictly a modern issue?
Post by: Thorsteinn on 2015-05-29, 20:03:07
Gods you guys are making me want to go 14th cen so bad. Maille, Klappavisor, Corazina's, Pembridge helm, & all the other sexiness.
Title: Re: Historical Accuracy in Maille- are Bingo Wings strictly a modern issue?
Post by: Sir Rodney on 2015-05-30, 03:23:22
Gods you guys are making me want to go 14th cen so bad. Maille, Klappavisor, Corazina's, Pembridge helm, & all the other sexiness.

Come to the dark side Thorsteinn.....
Title: Re: Historical Accuracy in Maille- are Bingo Wings strictly a modern issue?
Post by: Lord Dane on 2015-05-30, 07:36:30
Gods you guys are making me want to go 14th cen so bad. Maille, Klappavisor, Corazina's, Pembridge helm, & all the other sexiness.

Come to the dark side Thorsteinn.....

Yes!! The Pembridge helm is calling to you.
Title: Re: Historical Accuracy in Maille- are Bingo Wings strictly a modern issue?
Post by: Sir William on 2015-06-01, 19:58:17
Yea, I'm in a lot of trouble, too; think I got bit by the 14cM bug.
Title: Re: Historical Accuracy in Maille- are Bingo Wings strictly a modern issue?
Post by: Sir Martyn on 2015-06-02, 01:57:40
Dr. Capwell is a beast- I want his black harness!  First time I saw it I think I man-swooned.

LOL
Title: Re: Historical Accuracy in Maille- are Bingo Wings strictly a modern issue?
Post by: Sampf on 2015-06-24, 23:44:25
Makes me wish my 14th Century kit was cooler
Title: Re: Historical Accuracy in Maille- are Bingo Wings strictly a modern issue?
Post by: Sir William on 2015-06-25, 12:36:25
Don't wish for it, work toward it- it's a process.  Part of the fun, no?
Title: Re: Historical Accuracy in Maille- are Bingo Wings strictly a modern issue?
Post by: scott2978 on 2015-07-15, 19:42:35
Don't wish for it, work toward it- it's a process.  Part of the fun, no?

Well said.