Main > The Round Table

Top 10 Knights in European History

(1/2) > >>

Timothy:
http://www.toptenz.net/top-10-plus-one-knights-in-european-history.php

Hi all

Ok do you agree  or disagree with this list? Who would you add or remove?

Thanks

Timothy

Sir Patrick:
I would have left off the fictional characters. I'm surprised Robert the Bruce didn't make the cut, or Geoffrey de Chargny (sp?). What about Hugh de Paen?

Sir Martyn:
Honestly I think it's a mistake to mix real & fictional on this list - should be separate in my view.  And fully agree that de Charny should be on the "real" list.

Sir William:
At least not if you're calling it European history; they should do two different lists.  Then there's the whole Nine Worthies discussion.

Sir James A:
Agreed on the fictional vs historical meshing. Opens up a whole other world of literally impossible people.

Sir William, I also thought of the Nine Worthies.

Navigation

[0] Message Index

[#] Next page